Questão nº 26
Questão de Língua Inglesa · FCC PMSP AMCI 2025 - Prova 1 (nº 26)
Some ways to reinvent affordable housing in a post-pandemic world
Jan 20, 2022When more than 90 countries issued stay-at-home orders during the height of the COVID-19 pandemic, over 1 billion people across the globe sheltered in slums and informal settlements. Yet, these necessary public health measures offer scant defence against this potentially deadly virus if housing conditions are unsafe. The urgency of the pandemic response spotlighted an inescapable truth: chronic lack of safe and affordable housing in both advanced economies and developing nations is one of the biggest drivers of health and wealth disparities in our world.
As we grapple with how to adapt to ongoing waves of the virus and move towards rebuilding healthier, more equitable societies, we must expand the global supply of affordable housing by focusing on innovations that champion public health, sustainability and scalability. These three inextricably linked pillars can drive a new global housing framework that creates more equitable access to affordable housing and, as a result, improves health outcomes, fortifies disaster resilience and mitigates environmental impact.
Strategies and mindsets to reinvent affordable housing
- Home as a health solution
The connections between health and home have long been recognized by the medical community. Poor housing conditions have been linked to debilitating illnesses, from respiratory conditions to infectious diseases such as tuberculosis and influenza, and diarrhea, which is among the leading causes of childhood death worldwide. In many cases, simple upgrades to a home's roof, windows and floor can have a transformational impact on the health of a family and its surrounding community. A 2007 World Bank study found that replacing a home's dirt floors with concrete can lead to "a 78 percent reduction in parasitic infestations, a 49 percent reduction in diarrhea, an 81 percent reduction in anemia and a 36 to 96 percent improvement in cognitive development."
But even these small upgrades remain out of reach for many families. In emerging markets, it is common for households to build shelter incrementally as finances allow – a process that can take up to 30 years. The work starts and stops as resources are available, often resulting in increased construction costs and inconsistent quality of materials over time.
Housing entrepreneurs are working to bring affordable, scalable solutions to families that can mitigate preventable, life-threatening health concerns and can truly reinvent affordable housing. In Rwanda, upgrading to a concrete floor can cost more than two months' wages for the average family. Non-profit startup EarthEnable is working with African governments to support housing policy, and is using local materials and labour to provide an earthen floor alternative that delivers the same benefits as concrete at a quarter of the price.
As families strive to upgrade their homes, they need access – both physical and economical – to building products that will keep them safer.
- Investing in sustainable methods that work
In addition to addressing the connections between housing and health, trailblazers like EarthEnable are proving that affordable solutions can also be green solutions. By sourcing materials locally, they are streamlining supply chains, reducing greenhouse gas emissions and creating employment opportunities within the community.
With the construction sector consuming over 3 billion tons of raw materials each year – more than any other industry – we need to be more intentional about leveraging sustainable and recycled supplies. Again, startups are leading the way, leveraging low-cost modernizations for everything from lighting fixtures to pavers that are five to seven times more durable than concrete. In India, ReMaterials recycles packaging and agricultural waste into modular roof panels for families living in slums. These roofs have been shown to reduce a home's indoor air temperature by 10 degrees Celsius, improving quality of life and decreasing the risk of heatstroke.
Governments and housing non-profits have a critical role to play in ensuring that startups developing these green affordable housing innovations can scale their products and get them to vulnerable communities in greatest need.
- Scaling to reach 1 billion homes
The need to create more adequate housing opportunities around the world continues to grow exponentially as over 3 million people move to cities every week. Therefore, we must also sustainably and rapidly scale-up new construction.
Entrepreneurs around the world are rethinking housing construction from the ground up to produce more efficient solutions.
Increasing affordable housing supply also requires us to think differently about how we use and prioritize space. By emphasizing spatial needs and constraints in planning new developments, we can improve quality of life by enabling people to live closer to where they work while reducing traffic and environmental impact. Furthermore, data shows that mixed-income neighbourhoods produce better long-term health outcomes and economic mobility for individuals and families.
Governments, corporations and civil society have important roles to play in advancing disruptive solutions to the chronic shortage of safe, affordable housing around the globe. By supporting innovators with the capacity to expand quickly and effectively, together we can embrace a new global housing framework centred on sustainable and scalable shelter solutions. Only through collaboration can we reinvent affordable housing.
(Adapted from https://www.weforum.org/stories/2022/01/reinvent-affordable-housing-post-covid19-world-habitat-for-humanity/)
De acordo com o texto,
- Aa start-up EarthEnable está se valendo de materiais e mão de obra local para implantar pisos de concreto por um quarto do preço de suas concorrentes.
- Bas populações carentes estão sendo beneficiadas com financiamentos para adquirir materiais de construção a fim de tornar suas moradias mais salutares.
- Ca maioria das casas em Ruanda são tão precárias que representam sérios riscos à saúde. (alternativa correta)
- Dpor falta de recursos, muitas pessoas constroem suas moradias em etapas, o que pode levar até 30 anos.
- Eapesar da insalubridade de suas moradias, o custo dos materiais de construção e sua qualidade duvidosa têm desestimulado as pessoas a investirem em melhorias.
Resposta comentada
Gabarito Alternativa C
A compreensão de texto exige que o aluno identifique informações que estão explicitamente declaradas ou que podem ser diretamente inferidas a partir do que o texto apresenta, sem adicionar conhecimentos externos ou fazer generalizações não suportadas.
- (A) Incorreta: O texto afirma que a start-up EarthEnable oferece uma alternativa de piso de terra ("earthen floor alternative") que proporciona os mesmos benefícios do concreto por um quarto do preço, e não que ela implanta pisos de concreto.
- (B) Incorreta: O texto menciona que as famílias precisam de "acesso – tanto físico quanto econômico – a produtos de construção", mas não afirma que estão sendo beneficiadas com financiamentos para adquirir esses materiais. Pelo contrário, destaca a dificuldade em arcar com as melhorias.
- (C) Correta: O texto, na seção "Home as a health solution", discute como "condições precárias de moradia" ("Poor housing conditions") estão ligadas a "doenças debilitantes" e como "pequenas melhorias" podem ter um "impacto transformador na saúde". Em seguida, usa Ruanda como exemplo, afirmando que "melhorar para um piso de concreto pode custar mais de dois meses de salário para a família média". A startup EarthEnable trabalha para mitigar "preocupações de saúde evitáveis e que ameaçam a vida" oferecendo uma alternativa. Isso infere fortemente que as casas em Ruanda, que não possuem esses pisos (e outras melhorias), são precárias e representam sérios riscos à saúde, justificando a intervenção. A menção de "família média" e a atuação de uma ONG em parceria com o governo sugerem que essa é uma condição generalizada, tornando "a maioria" uma inferência razoável dentro do contexto.
- (D) Incorreta: Embora o texto afirme que "em mercados emergentes, é comum para as famílias construir abrigos incrementalmente conforme as finanças permitem – um processo que pode levar até 30 anos", esta é uma afirmação geral sobre "mercados emergentes", e não especificamente sobre a situação de saúde em Ruanda, que é o foco da seção onde Ruanda é mencionada e o que a alternativa C aborda. A alternativa D, embora factual no texto em um contexto mais amplo, não é a inferência mais direta ou relevante para a situação específica de Ruanda no contexto de "soluções de saúde", como é a alternativa C.
- (E) Incorreta: O texto diz que as melhorias "permanecem fora do alcance de muitas famílias" ("remain out of reach for many families"), o que indica falta de acesso ou recursos, não que elas estão "desestimuladas a investir" por causa do custo ou da qualidade duvidosa. Na verdade, o texto sugere que as famílias se esforçam para melhorar suas casas ("As families strive to upgrade their homes").
Fonte: FCC PMSP AMCI 2025 - Prova 1 Conhecimentos Comuns (AMCI - Geral) (Caderno Tipo 004). Reproduzida para fins de estudo.